Hi Kent,
Like you, I rarely find remakes as satisfying as the original recordings of songs. But as comparisons of anything artistic are completely subjective in the eye or ear of the beholder, I think the trump card is often held by whatever rendition of a song the listener heard first.
For example, I never heard the Soul Brother Six’s original 1967 version of “Some Kind of Wonderful” until well into the ‘80s. As a result, Grand Funk’s 1976 cover remains definitive for me, although I do know better.
Anyway, when I was a writer for Casey Kasem’s “AT 40,” we did several stories about Johnny Rivers and Linda Ronstadt being the “King and Queen of Hit Remakes.” Nevertheless, I’d be hard-pressed to select any of their covers as the definitive take on the early Rock and Motown tunes they recorded. Linda may have gotten close with her version of Roy Orbison’s “Blue Bayou,” but that is debatable.
The only act that I feel consistently bettered previous hit chestnuts was the Beach Boys. Doo Wop purists may disagree with me, but Brian and the Boys’ updates of Frankie Lymon’s “Why Do Fools Fall In Love,” the Mystics’ “Hushabye” and the Students’ “I’m So Young” are inarguably stellar. Even “Barbara Ann,” which Carl Wilson so dreaded every night on-stage, makes the Regents’ original sound robotic.
Conversely, while it was nice to have the Beach Boys back on the charts, few would argue that latter-day remakes such as “Rock & Roll Music” and “Hot Fun In the Summertime” eclipsed Chuck Berry and Sly & the Family Stone.
But when it comes to these next four cover versions, the Beach Boys own them lock, stock & barrel:
“Do You Wanna Dance”
More a nod to Del Shannon’s own prior remake than the Bobby Freeman original, Dennis Wilson’s one and only lead vocal on a hit single made this song his for all eternity. Among big brother Brian’s many lauded talents, his ability to assign the lead to the appropriate man among five great singers was unfailingly brilliant.
This recording, once considered a toss-away Top 20 hit, so perfectly captures Dennis’s energy and sex appeal and looms larger today in the Beach Boys’ canon than it did at the time. Live bootlegs from the ‘60s reveal the hysteria Denny’s performance of this tune generated among the teen and pre-teen girls in the audience.
Although buried in a dense Spectorish-sorta mix, Brian’s background vocal arrangement is amazing, as is his stratospheric falsetto. This is one of many examples where Brian’s skills as an arranger are working more subliminally than right in your face.
“Sloop John B.”
The average listener doesn’t know that this Beach Boys classic started out as a Carl Sandberg poem and was previously released in song form by the Weavers and the Kingston Trio.
The Beach Boys pinched their early striped shirts from the Trio, and Al Jardine was and is a big fan of their fellow Capitol Records act. Al’s never really gotten his due for suggesting this song to Brian, who opted to record this amidst the “Pet Sounds” sessions, despite the fact that he was not much of a Kingston Trio fan, finding the group somewhat quaint and soulless.
Still, Brian heard something in the simplicity of the song, which played counterpoint to one of his greatest instrumental tracks and most complex vocal arrangements. One of the truly finest Beach Boys singles.
“I Can Hear Music”
Brian Wilson’s obsession with the Ronettes’ “Be My Baby” is legendary. It was and remains his favorite 45. But this remake of a late-in-the-game Ronettes single (I think it peaked at #100 on the Billboard chart in 1966) is strictly a Carl Wilson production.
Cut in 1968 for the Beach Boys’ last album for Capitol Records, the instrumental track is an exercise in spare simplicity — drums, acoustic guitars and piano. But its grandeur emanates from stacks of vocals that would and did make Brian proud of his baby brother. This, in fact, was the first Beach Boys single not to include any participation from the elder Wilson brother.
As such, it was also proof that the other members of the group were now capable of creating sonic masterpieces that rivaled those of their genius, sometime leader. And the majestic lead performance turned in by Carl clearly established him as the finest voice among a peerless vocal ensemble.
“Cottonfields”
The Beach Boys final LP for Capitol, “20/20,” was a hodge-podge of tunes from the vault, recent singles and filler. Nevertheless, it turned out to be a very strong collection, albeit a poor-seller at the time.
With tracks produced by individual members of the group, both Carl and Dennis Wilson made strong showings. While big brother Bri was represented by aborted “Smile” offerings and tunes snatched back from a trio he was producing named Redwood (soon to be re-dubbed Three Dog Night), he did find time to tackle a remake of an old folk classic.
“Cottonfields” was written and first recorded by Huddie Ledbetter, best-known as “Leadbelly,” in 1940. In the intervening years, it became something of a folk standard, as dozens of other artists added it to their repertoires. Brian Wilson’s take on it, featuring Al Jardine on the lead, never quite escaped a languid, mid-tempo beat.
Feeling that the track was “under-produced,” Al convinced the band to re-record an uptempo take on the tune during one of the Beach Boys’ rehearsal sessions. The group members were augmented by a few sessions musicians, most notably Red Rhodes on pedal steel guitar, which gave the track a decidedly more country feel.
“Cottonfields,” Version Two, became the Beach Boys final single for Capitol Records. And while it stiffed in the U.S., it became a Top Ten hit throughout much of the world, even topping the charts in many European countries.
A modified Brian Wilson arrangement with a more dynamic production courtesy of Al Jardine, this is a brilliant Beach Boys single and a great bookend to “Sloop John B.”
These four remakes certainly eclipse the original recordings.
Regards,
Scott Paton
The Beach Boys' recording of "I Can Hear Music" is, without a doubt, one of my absolute favorites by them. A GREAT recording that I crank up every time it comes on. (I even like the country version they recorded with Kathy Troccoli for their "Stars And Stripes" CD ... by far the strongest track on the disk.) And I would agree that "Do You Wanna Dance", "Sloop John B" (also recorded by Jimmie Rodgers by the way) and "Barbara Ann" deserve a spot on this list as well. ("Cottonfields"? "Why Do Fools Fall In Love"? Maybe not so much ... and quite honestly I don't need to EVER hear their version "Rock And Roll Music" again!!!)
Anybody else got some favorite remakes they want to share? (kk)
re: MORE MUSIC MERGERS:
How about Peter Paul and Mary Wells
Peter and Gordon Lightfoot
Chad and Jeremy Piven
Jackie Wilson Pickett
Stevie Ray Wonder
Styx and Stones
Elvis Presley Costello
Carly Simon and Garfunkel
Buddy Guy Lombardo
Freddy and the Dreamers and the Flock
A Flock of Byrds
re: THE SONNY GERACI BENEFIT CONCERT:
Hey Kent -
Wanted to let you know that The Rip Chords have been added to the Sonny Geraci Benefit Concert taking place in November in Ohio. We're looking forward to being there, and helping with Sonny's cause. He is a living legend, and we're honored to be there. Thanks to Rae and Dennis Tufano for putting this show together!
Mitch Schecter
That's great news, Mitch. We're still kicking around the idea of bringing the show to Chicago, too ... a GREAT chance to help raise money for Sonny's medical bills as well as an opportunity for the artists to add a second midwest gig to their itinerary and help control some of the traveling expense. (Plus that would mean I'd finally get the chance to see you guys!!!) I'll keep you posted. (kk)
Dennis Tufano tells us that a few more acts have been booked ... and several others are trying to rearrange their schedules in order to participate ... so watch more future updates.
Currently on board:
Dennis Tufano (The Buckinghams), Terry Sylvester (The Hollies), Ron Dante (The Archies), Johnny Farino (Santo and Johnny), Jim Gold (Gallery), Jimy Sohns (The Shadows Of Knight), The Rip Chords, Pat Upton (The Spiral Starecase) and The 1910 Fruit Gum Company. The concert is scheduled for November 15th and 16th at The Z-Plex in Streetsboro, Ohio and tickets are $35 per person. Interested artists can contact us and we'll be happy to pass the information along.
Also, artists unable to attend due to scheduling conflict are encouraged to donate some autographed memorabilia to be sold at auction to help raise funds for Sonny's medical bills. Again, keep watching these pages for more details. (kk)
re: OTHER SHOWS:
Yay Kent,
Finally, a concert! And a great one, too! Last night The Buckinghams made it (after an air delay from Arkansas) to The Wolf Den at Mohegan Sun. We had to stand in line an extra hour to let them plug everything in and do a quick sound-check, but then we were seated. My friend and I ended up front and center between Carl and Nick. (side-note: standing in line to see the 60's, in your 60's, takes a tougher toll on your body than it did when you were 13 ... just sayin') The first couple songs had me worried ... not because they weren't good ... but because Carl's mic wasn't loud enough. BUT the awesome crew at The Den soon fixed that situation, and the show magnified in intensity. All The Bucks' songs were there, but this solo appearance gave Carl, Nick, Dave Zane, Bruce and Bruce (Rocky); a chance to rock some other great oldies but goodies. Since Carl and Nick had appeared in the last three Happy Together Tours, they sang a tribute to the entertainers, past and present, who have toured with them. Too many other great memories to put in print, but I am proud to say that Carl and Nick are using Dave and his abilities to their advantage to make these shows more than our expectations are. A very quick introduction in the autograph line and we were off to recap and eat. Later, I went into the computer lounge to type Facebook updates and reviews, and Carl walks in ... what me nervous? As I'm typing about him, and he wants to read over my shoulder? OH YES!! So Carl, this piece was typed the next morning at the same computer where I left you last night. Gotcha!
Shelley J Sweet-Tufano
Kent, both Carl and I remarked how nice you are. :-)
I will be sitting in at Jimmy Vivino's Rockabilly Revue at BB Kings in NYC along with Robert Gordon, Johnny A, Lee Rocker, Anton Fig and probably more 9/7. Come on down and slide back to the 50's with us!
By the way, the Michael Bloomfield box set I have just spent a year working on will be out in January, 2014.
Sincerely,
@l k%per
With Forgotten Hits readers all over the world, we're happy to help promote Bob Lind's upcoming European tour. And, if any of you DO happen to catch any of these shows, please report back to us ... and let Bob know that you heard about it in Forgotten Hits! (kk)
I'm sending this to everyone -- even those of you on this side of The Pond. One never knows who will be where when.
To my Brit and Spanish friends and fans, and anyone who may happen to be in Spain or the U.K. in late August or early September:
In one week I'll be leaving for Europe. Six shows in England; Three in Spain.
More specifically:
U. K.
Friday, Aug. 30 = Dorset (End of the Road Festival)
Monday, Sept. 2 = Brighton (The Greys)
Tuesday, Sept. 3 = London (The Slaughtered Lamb)
Wednesday, Sept. 4 = Sheffield (The Greystones)
Thursday, Sept. 5 = Winchester (The Railway)
Friday, Sept 6 = Bristol (The Grain Barge)
SPAIN
Thursday, Sept 12 = Bilbao (Colegio de Abogados)
Friday, Sept 13 = Madrid (Siroco)
Saturday, Sept 14 = Madrid (Radiocity Discos) show and signing.
Those are the broad strokes. For specifics on venue locations, ticket sales and other info, please consult the Gigs Page of my web site: http://boblind.com/gigs/ Hope to see a whole slew of you there.